Accessibility options

Judge rules against BP on oil spill

Business news

Judge rules against BP on oil spill
BP's arguments over compensation for the 2010 Gulf oil spill were rejected by a US judge.


Published: 11:51pm, 24th December 2013
Updated: 12:20pm, 27th December 2013

A US judge tonight rejected BP's argument that a multibillion-dollar settlement over the company's massive 2010 Gulf oil spill should not compensate businesses if they cannot directly trace their losses to the spill.

District Judge Carl Barbier said in his ruling the settlement was designed to avoid the delays that would result from a "claim-by claim analysis" of whether each claim can be traced to the spill.

Earlier this month, a three-judge panel of the 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Judge Barbier erred when he initially refused to consider BP's "causation" arguments.

In response to that ruling, he agreed with plaintiffs' lawyers that BP cannot make these arguments because the company took a contradictory position on the same issue when it urged him last year to approve the settlement.

Judge Barbier said requiring claimants to meet BP's proposed requirements for connecting losses to the spill would bring the claims process to a "virtual standstill".

Steve Herman and Jim Roy, two of the plaintiffs' lawyers who brokered the settlement with BP, said Gulf Coast business owners should be pleased that Judge Barbier "once again rejected BP's efforts to rewrite history and the settlement".

They said: "The court reaffirmed that the transparent, objective formulas spelled out in the agreement are the only way to determine a claimant's eligibility and causation."

BP spokesman Geoff Morrell said the company disagrees with Judge Barbier's decision. He also said court-appointed claims administrator Patrick Juneau's interpretation of settlement terms renders the deal "unlawful".

Mr Morrell said: "Awarding money to claimants with losses that were not caused by the spill is contrary to the language of the settlement and violates established principles of class action law.

"BP intends to seek appropriate appellate remedies to correct this error."

On December 5, Judge Barbier temporarily suspended settlement payments to businesses while he reconsidered the company's causation arguments.

He said Mr Juneau's office would continue accepting and processing business claims but would not make final decisions or payments until the matter is resolved.

For months, BP has argued that the judge and Mr Juneau misinterpreted settlement terms in ways that could force the company to pay for billions of dollars in bogus or inflated claims by businesses.

In October, the same 5th Circuit panel instructed Judge Barbier to craft a "narrowly-tailored" order that bars Mr Juneau from paying certain claims.

BP, however, argued Judge Barbier did not go far enough when he issued an order to comply with the 5th Circuit's directives.

AP

Data provided by moneysupermarket Best Buy Credit Cards - For Balance Transfers
The data displayed on this table was correct when published at 15:03 30/06/2015
Credit card provider Balance
Transfer
Purchases Representative
APR (Variable)
Card provider - Barclaycard

Barclaycard

Platinum Credit Card with Extended Balance Transfer

0.00%
36 months
2.39% fee
0.00%
6 months
18.90%

Representative Example:

If you spend £1200.00 at a purchase interest rate of 18.90% (variable) your Representative APR will be 18.90% (variable).

Apply

Card provider - Halifax

Halifax

Balance Transfer Credit Card

0.00%
36 months
2.49% fee
0.00%
6 months
18.90%

Representative Example:

If you spend £1200.00 at a purchase interest rate of 18.95% (variable) your Representative APR will be 18.90% (variable).

Apply

Card provider - Virgin Money

Virgin Money

36 Month Balance Transfer Credit Card

0.00%
36 months
2.50% fee
0.00%
6 months
18.90%

Representative Example:

If you spend £1200.00 at a purchase interest rate of 18.90% (variable) your Representative APR will be 18.90% (variable).

Apply

Data provided by moneysupermarket Best Buy Savings Accounts - For Easy Access
The data displayed on this table was correct when published at 15:03 30/06/2015
Savings account provider Interest
Rate (AER)
Min Investment Notice
Savings provider - Birmingham Midshires

Birmingham Midshires

BM Online Extra (Issue 17)

1.5% 1000 none

Eligibility criteria:

Must be aged 18 or over

Apply

Savings provider - RCI Bank UK

RCI Bank UK

Freedom Savings Account

1.5% 100 none

Eligibility criteria:

Available to UK residents aged 18 or over.

Apply

Savings provider - krbs

krbs

Online Easy Access Account Issue 1

1.45% 1000 none

Eligibility criteria:

You are a UK resident aged 18 or over

Apply

Savings provider - Virgin Money

Virgin Money

Defined Access E-Saver

1.41% 1 none

Eligibility criteria:

You must be aged 16 years or older

Apply

Savings provider - Tesco Bank

Tesco Bank

Internet Saver

1.35% 1 none

Eligibility criteria:

Available to UK residents aged 18 or over.

Apply

Data provided by moneysupermarket Best Buy Current Accounts - For Rewards
The data displayed on this table was correct when published at 15:04 30/06/2015
Current account provider Reward Overdraft
Rate (EAR)
Current account provider - first direct

first direct

1st Account

£100 cashback when you switch 15.90

Apply

Current account provider - Santander

Santander

123 Current Account

Up to 3% cashback on household bills 0.00

Apply

Current account provider - Halifax

Halifax

Reward Current Account

Up to £160 in the 1st year 0.00

Apply

Data provided by moneysupermarket Best Buy Loans
The data displayed on this table was correct when published at 15:03 30/06/2015
Loan provider Headline Rate Payment per month Total charge for credit Total amount you repay
Loans provider - The Loans Engine

The Loans Engine

4.00% £294.92 £617.19 £10617.19

Representative Example:

If you borrow £10000.00 over 3 years at a Representative APR of 4.00% fixed and an annual interest rate of 4.00% you would pay the above.

Apply

Loans provider - Avant Credit

Avant Credit

48.50% £482.27 £7361.73 £17361.73

Representative Example:

If you borrow £10000.00 over 3 years at a Representative APR of 48.50% fixed and an annual interest rate of 48.50% you would pay the above.

Apply

Loans provider - Fluent Money

Fluent Money

4.70% £297.92 £725.26 £10725.26

Representative Example:

If you borrow £10000.00 over 3 years at a Representative APR of 4.70% fixed and an annual interest rate of 4.70% you would pay the above.

Apply

Data provided by moneysupermarket Best Buy Mortgages - For Remortgage
The data displayed on this table was correct when published at 15:03 30/06/2015
Mortgage provider Interest
Rate (AER)
Max LTV Duration
Mortgage provider - Furness Building Society Discount 60% LTV

Furness Building Society Discount 60% LTV

0.99% 60% For 2 years

Apply

Mortgage provider - HSBC Discount 60% LTV

HSBC Discount 60% LTV

0.99% 60% For 2 years

Apply

Mortgage provider - Co-operative Bank Fixed 60% LTV

Co-operative Bank Fixed 60% LTV

1.14% 60% Until 31/08/2017

Apply

Mortgage provider - Furness Building Society Discount 60% LTV

Furness Building Society Discount 60% LTV

1.15% 60% For 2 years

Apply

Mortgage provider - Post Office Money Tracker 75% LTV

Post Office Money Tracker 75% LTV

1.24% 75% Until 30/09/2017

Apply

Advertisement starts



Advertisement ends

Travel offers

Add Add
Scenic Sardinia holiday
Lodore Falls Hotel
Luxury Turkey holiday with private pool
G&V Royal Mile Hotel Edinburgh
Sardinia foodie holiday with car hire
Carbis Bay Hotel
Stunning Iceland summer break
5* London mystery hotel
Tuscany wine & food holiday
Spitbank Fort


Secret EscapesJoin now for Free

Save up to 70% on luxury hotels and holidays


£30 voucher to spend at M&S

£30 voucher to spend at M&S

Plus interest free balance transfers and purchases

Lloyds Bank Platinum Credit Card

Lloyds Bank Platinum Credit Card

10 month balance transfer & purchase card

Fix Your Finances 2015

Make more out of your money in 2015 with these tips and offers

Start your solar journey today

Start your solar journey today

Find out how to slash your energy bill in 2015 with solar panels

Skip NHS queues

Skip NHS queues

Protect you and your family with Private Health Insurance. Find the right policy for you.

Advertisement starts


Advertisement

Advertisement ends